How Beliefs about Expertise Shape Expert Recognition
Written by Emlyon professor Lauren Keating & Victoria University of Wellington professor Benjamin Walker.
Amid technological change, widespread disease, climate crises, as well as economic and political instability, expertise is critical to humanity now more than ever before. And yet, anti-intellectualism currently runs rife, characterised by a preference for simple, unnuanced solutions, and a growing distrust and disdain for experts.
In public health, for instance, misinformation about vaccines and disregard for scientific evidence have contributed to a rise in once largely eradicated diseases, putting vulnerable people and communities at risk. In the realm of business, entry-level workers are being replaced by generative AI, despite research highlighting that generative AI is used best as a tool to complement entry-level work. Such examples thus beg an urgent question: Why are people disengaging with expertise?
Our research: Lay theories of expertise
For the past several years, we have attempted to address this question from a psychological standpoint. Specifically, we have investigated people’s varied lay beliefs about expertise, as well as how these beliefs affect which experts (if any) they pay attention to. This research was kick-started in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, wherein the value of expertise was routinely debated in public discourse.
In the exploratory phase of our research, we asked 100 participants to describe in their own words their understanding of expertise. We then analysed over 100 posts on Twitter (now X) that mentioned experts or expertise. These studies were then followed by a word sorting study where 700 individuals needed to identify and group different terms (e.g., “knowledge” or “qualifications”) into broader themes on expertise. What we found across these studies is that, for many people, possessing exceptional knowledge is a key feature of expertise. Moreover, people tended to believe that expertise involves solving problems and getting results – and that having specialist education also qualifies someone as an expert.
These findings are arguably unsurprising. Indeed, it can be useful to identify experts based on how much knowledge they possess or how impressive their track record seems to be. However, the issue we see emerging from this research is that relying on these few criteria can leave people at risk for identifying experts as those who simply act as possessing considerable knowledge, project (over)confidence, and who may even only have tangentially relevant qualifications.
Interestingly, fewer people across our exploratory studies held the belief that expertise should also be about intellectual humility. In other words, an expert could be identified not merely by their exceptional knowledge, but by their humble awareness of where the limitations in their knowledge lie.
What does this mean for identifying experts?
In an age of rampant misinformation where the loudest (and often incorrect) voices are heard, managers and leaders need to take stock of their own assumptions about expertise. Are experts only those who know a lot, or should they also have a consistent track record of problem-solving? Is it even realistic for experts to consistently be right about the complex problems they’re trying to solve? And how much weight should a leader give to someone’s qualifications?
A leader’s assumptions about what constitutes expertise are not necessarily wrong. What we see from our research, however, is that such assumptions likely need to be tempered with a belief that expertise also involves intellectual humility, such that an expert can astutely recognise the limitations in their knowledge. While some leaders might presume that this humility reflects a lack of know-how or confidence, it is quite the contrary. Years of research make it clear that the more competent someone is, the more likely they are to have an awareness of their shortcomings. Put simply, an expert often knows what they don’t know.
Can leaders change their beliefs about expertise?
In the second phase of our research, we conducted an online experiment with 200 managers. Participants were shown one of three videos: one that emphasised the benefits of humble expertise, another that showcased the advantages of a confident expertise, and a third video serving as a control, which explained different negotiation styles. After viewing the videos, participants were instructed to imagine collaborating with a legal expert who openly acknowledged the limitations of his knowledge, and then evaluate how much of an expert they perceived him to be. Those who had watched the brief video emphasising intellectual humility perceived the lawyer as more expert than those who had watched a video either about confident expertise or negotiation.
In a follow-up experiment, we recruited 240 managers with hiring experience. They viewed their respective videos prior to reviewing an application package from a job candidate for a fictional sustainability specialist role. Some applications depicted the candidate as a highly confident and self-assured woman or man, while others portrayed a humble woman or man who acknowledged their limitations. We found that when managers watched a video on intellectual humility, they perceived the job candidate expressing their limitations as more expert, while those who watched the video about confident expertise evaluated the self-assured candidate as more expert.
This finding suggests that people recognise experts on the basis of what they believe expertise should be, and not necessarily on whether someone is a good fit for the job. Moreover, we also found that expert recognition was guided by the gender of the candidate. No matter what belief was most dominant, participants recognised the woman (but not the man) as less expert when she behaved in a way that was not in line with the manager’s dominant belief about expertise.
It is clear that beliefs about expertise—even those induced momentarily—can impact who people do and do not recognise as experts, with women paying a higher price when they act outside the bounds of people’s assumptions of expertise. It is thus important for leaders to confront how their beliefs about expertise could be impeding them from considering a more diverse pool of experts.
Lauren Keating is an Associate Professor of organisational behaviour and psychology at Emlyon Business School in France, as well as a member of the Behavioural Research in Organisations Centre. She studies cognition and lay theories, as well as motivation, well-being, and leadership and career development.
Benjamin Walker is a Senior Lecturer in organisational behaviour at Te Herenga Waka–Victoria University of Wellington in New Zealand. He studies experts and expertise, the work-identity interface, counter-perspectives on motivation and Māori and Indigenous employees.