Workplace AI processes disengage employees
New research finds mandated AI adoption quietly emerging as a retention risk for employers.
The findings, shared by HR tool Click Boarding, reveal that AI processes being implemented across workplaces are currently driving disengagement instead of delivering productivity gains.
- Employees describe quitting over mandatory AI tools that reduce their autonomy, create extra processes and make their work feel less meaningful.
- A disconnect is apparent as only 4% of employers report employee resistance as a barrier to AI adoption, while nearly a quarter of workers (22%) say they would consider leaving a job because of this.
- A Gallop survey found that employee engagement has fallen to its lowest level in 10 years, while job-seeking activity is at a decade high.
Search data also shows a 9% year-over-year increase in global searches for “quitting my job” (22,000 monthly searches) alongside emerging queries such as “made to use AI at work” (1,000 monthly searches).
Information, technology and professional services are currently leading AI adoption in the U.S., with labor demand for AI skills also rising sharply in these sectors (80% YoY increase for information and 31% for professional services, according to Stanford’s AI Index).
Click Boarding’s research analyses Glassdoor reviews and social media discussions to reveal employees’ frustrations with AI use at work and the reasons they are quitting. Common themes include:
- A desire to be included in AI-related discussions with leadership and discomfort with developing AI tools and reporting on their performance, due to fears that the systems they train could eventually replace their own roles.
- A preference to spend longer doing something without AI due to creativity and quality issues, with some people lying about their AI use to meet mandatory usage requirements.
- Frustrations around poor AI performance blamed on “bad prompts” and feelings that management has too high expectations of AI to replace job responsibilities it is not yet capable of.
One Glassdoor review described their organisation’s AI tools as “AI Big Brother”, negatively mentioning having daily screen time tracked down to the minute. Another suggested that those who do not engage with, or believe in, AI, face worsened career prospects.
It is recommended that employers update compliance-driven policies to include AI guidelines, ensure employees acknowledge them, and share key AI process information early in onboarding. Providing regular feedback channels allows organisations to address concerns proactively, helping reduce retention risks and keeping employees engaged as AI adoption evolves.
Visit Click Boarding’s website to learn more about the retention risk of getting AI adoption wrong.