The Brave Face Gap: What Your Engagement Survey Can Never Tell You
By Maria Paviour
HR teams pour months into their engagement survey, only to be told by the data that everyone is “fine.” Our research suggests otherwise: employees have learned to put on a brave face, and the survey can’t see behind it.
For many in HR, the annual engagement survey is a slog: chasing participation, pulling together the data, then reporting back to a senior team that just wants to know if the business is “doing ok”. One HR manager told me exactly that. A Wellbeing Lead put it differently: “Our engagement and wellbeing survey results don’t seem to add up. Something is going on. We don’t know what.”
Every HR professional we interviewed for our Upside Down People System report said the same thing. And with 25 years of data behind us, we found a clear cultural shift 18 years ago. Employees stopped feeling “somewhat stressed” and started “putting on a brave face” instead.
Engagement surveys cannot see behind that brave face. People can be so absorbed in their work that they’re heading toward harmful exhaustion, and still tell you they’re fine. If you rely on survey results alone, and can’t see the people who say they’re ok while feeling overwhelmed, you may be looking at a false paradise. The more entrenched Brave Face Syndrome becomes, the less able people are to recognise it in themselves.
The science behind it
The body responds to stress through allostasis, an unconscious nervous system response that lets us react to danger before we’ve had time to think. As stressors build, so does our “allostatic load”: the body physically ramps up its ability to cope. In the workplace, this has a paradoxical effect. Instead of alerting us to rising danger, it normalises it. That normalising doesn’t reduce the impact on our bodies and brains. It does the opposite.
Employee AJ: “You just keep going, and then they say ‘you’ve missed your target again’ and put you on performance management. I know I’m missing my target.” They put a hand over their mouth. “It’s like, where has my brain gone? I’m good at my job. Or I was. I don’t want to be this person.”
When employees believe that targets and endurance are everything, organisations get the opposite of what they want. The harder you push, the less you get back. This normalisation, or “psychological adaptation,” strips employees of the ability to judge what’s safe or unreasonable, until something snaps. That’s why a standard survey can’t see the strain building underneath.
Kirsten: “Work has been relentless. I don’t get a moment. And when I get home to my kids, I’m like this… monster.” She broke down. “No one can know. I’m a single mum. I just can’t lose my job.”
Psychological adaptation has another cost: it reduces cognitive capacity. The brain shuts down the pathways it needs for learning and creativity. Endurance cultures (hard driven, target focused, rigid) are self-defeating the moment you fill them with actual human beings.
Jack: “I keep making mistakes and having to correct them. Really silly mistakes, embarrassing ones. If I didn’t have to correct things, I reckon I’d have time for a lunch break.” He laughed, grimly. “And some sanity.”
Busy isn’t the enemy
Here’s the other paradox: busy environments and high goals aren’t dangerous in themselves. They can make work healthy. A healthy workplace needs dynamic energy, more like running a marathon with short sprints and rests than sprinting flat out all day. When people can apply their energy purposefully, and get properly absorbed in the work, it’s deeply satisfying.
A standard engagement survey can’t tell you where Brave Face Syndrome is hurting performance, where the risk of sickness absence is building, or how far your people’s brains are functioning, or shutting down, as a direct result of the culture.
“Culture” can feel abstract, a word that describes everyone and no one. The real test is simpler. Do your people feel safe to speak truth to power? Will they tell you the way you manage them makes it hard to do their job? And, most tellingly: what do people do when no one is looking? If they’re gaming the system to survive, that’s a clear sign of an endurance culture, not a healthy one.
First signs to watch for
“I’m fine”: Don’t take this at face value. It’s a knee-jerk response, and emotions are the last thing the brain processes, not the first. Someone can have a physical reaction to something long before they’ve worked out what it means to them.
Reactivity: An early warning sign, and one worth acting on. Anxiety, anger or frustration can look like difficult behaviour, but there’s usually a reasonable chance you can support the person underneath it.
Diminishing returns on performance: If someone is having to redo their work more than once, take note. Skilled, conscientious employees can lose concentration and competence when their cognitive capacity is being undermined.
Loss of purpose: Someone just turning up, without any real sense of involvement, is a sign that strain is eating into their engagement.
Fatigue: A clear signal that strain has taken hold: exhaustion and a sense of being overwhelmed.
Social withdrawal: When a team member stops wanting to join in, at work or socially, it often means they’re struggling to keep their head above water and their nervous system is shutting down.
Engagement surveys can’t surface the hidden strain that produces a Brave Face. Human brains don’t perform at their best in cultures where endurance is the norm.
I’ll leave the last word to Amina: “I had to get another job, but at the time even trying felt… impossible.” She paused. “Everyone said, ‘oh, it’s the culture.’ I wasn’t thinking about culture. I was surviving.” Then she smiled. “So I’m lucky, I guess, because my new job, I feel part of something. We talk, about everything, anything. And things get done, things change. I suppose we all just want to do the best we can, don’t we?”