HR & Payroll experts express doubts on government’s announced “end to consultation culture”

Depositphotos_800238450_L

Written by our Guest Blogger, Steve Herbert

 

Occupational Health Assessment Limited’s survey suggests that employers still value involvement in decision making detail. 

The Chancellor of the Exchequer, John Healey MP, recently announced plans to end the “consultation culture” at HM Treasury and other government departments. However, a recent survey by Occupational Health Assessment Limited found that almost half of employers would be able to offer informed views and insights on such consultations if asked.

The survey of 130 employers representing more than 1.25 million employees worldwide was undertaken last month and found that almost half (48%) of employers would like to at least read and understand consultations that will influence or dictate their everyday employment and payroll practices.  More than 1 in every 3 employers would go further and actively respond to the consultation either directly (32%) or via a representative organisation such as a trade association (3%).

Magnus Kauders, Managing Director of Occupational Health Assessment Limited, commented;

“It is currently unclear how far the government intends to go with their proposed reduction in formal consultations.

However, our survey shows that when businesses learn of consultations that impact their legal employment responsibilities, they want the opportunity to respond, highlight oversights and suggest improvements to government proposals.”

The Occupational Health Assessment Limited survey also suggests a communication failure in the current consultation system.  Just over half (55%) of employers were not aware of three important government consultations linked to employment practices that had been published shortly before the summer break.  Yet all three of the consultations were due to close in the early autumn of 2026.  The three consultations highlighted were;

  • Holiday Pay Compliance & Enforcement Consultation (closed 22/09/26)
  • Workplace Monitoring Technologies Consultation (closed 30/09/26)
  • Equal Pay & Pay Discrimination Consultation (closes 27/10/26)

Claire McCusker, Practice Director, at Occupational Health Assessment Limited, observed;

“Our survey – and the Chancellor’s proposed changes – highlights something of a paradox in the current consultation process.

Many employers can and will offer practical insights into formal government consultations that could impact millions of British workers. However, they can do so only if they know when consultations are published and have enough time to review and respond to those proposals.

Whilst we understand the need for government to make big political decisions without a cumbersome formal consultation process, we do feel that there is a case to be made for a more robust layer of conversation with employers.  Such consultations can focus on the small but important details of any announced change which could make the difference between success and failure of a new policy.

We hope the government will take the concerns of employers seriously as they look to reform their consultation exercises in the years ahead.”

For full details of the Occupational Health Assessment Limited research findings please scroll down.

—

Survey details & results

The anonymous survey was undertaken on Wednesday 9th September 2026 as part of the quarterly Occupational Health Assessment Employment Webinars series.  130 senior HR, Finance, Payroll and C-Suite professionals responded representing UK employers in the Private, Public, and Third Sector.  In total these organisations employ at least 1.25 million worldwide employees.

Survey results and questions:

Q1) Were you previously aware of the three recently published government consultations?

  • Yes; we were aware of all three of these consultations (4%)
  • Yes; we were aware of at least one of these three consultations (34%)
  • No; we were not aware of these consultations (55%)
  • I’m not sure (8%)

 

Q2) Will you read and respond to these government consultations?

  • Yes; we will read and respond if appropriate (32%)
  • Yes; we will read and ask representative organisations to respond (3%)
  • Yes; we will read but not respond (13%)
  • No; we are unlikely to read these consultations (19%)
  • I’m not sure (33%)

About Occupational Health Assessment Limited

Occupational Health Assessment Limited is a team of highly qualified and experienced specialists who aim to help employers identify and reduce their workforce health risks.

Headquartered in Guildford, Surrey, the team delivers occupational health support right across the UK and can provide assessment appointments within 48 working hours of a request.  This rapid response service ensures that businesses are provided with all the key data to make robust and swift decisions to reduce absence, support employee wellbeing, avoid presenteeism, mitigate litigation and avoid unwanted negative publicity.

Occupational Health Assessment Limited are a Certified B-Corporation and SEQOHS Accredited occupational health provider and have been independently assessed as meeting high standards of care and service by the Faculty of Occupational Medicine.

Occupational Health Assessment Ltd in numbers:

410         years of combined OH and employee benefits expertise and experience

185         appointments available weekly

325         thousand client employees covered

“The service is congratulated on their high level of appreciation and support regarding individual experience, knowledge, and skills and the ongoing development of their staff” SEQOHS Assessment Report

 

Website:  www.occupationalhealthassessment.com