Majority of UK employers not effectively using misconduct data to prevent future workplace issues
Most UK employers are collecting data on workplace misconduct, but the majority are not yet using it effectively to identify risks and prevent future issues, according to new research from Culture Shift.
A survey of 300 senior HR professionals found that only 41% consistently aggregate and analyse misconduct or speak-up data to identify patterns. A further 41% said they only do this occasionally, while 18% either don’t analyse their data for patterns at all or are unsure whether this happens within their organisation.
When it comes to turning that data into action, just 43% said they regularly use reporting insights to inform preventative action. 42% say they occasionally do, while 15% said they rarely or never do so – meaning that for a significant proportion of organisations, reporting data is being collected but not used to address the root causes of workplace issues before they escalate.
This issue is particularly urgent considering that from October, employers of all sizes will be required to demonstrate they have taken “all reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment. As part of this, they need to be able to evidence proactive prevention of issues, not simply the fact that they collect the data.
How misconduct data is managed is also a concern. Two thirds (67%) of organisations still use manual methods such as Word documents or spreadsheets to manage misconduct or speak-up data, while 6% do not collate this data at all. Almost a quarter (22%) are managing misconduct and speak up data entirely through manual methods, highlighting a clear gap in maturity and consistency of data management practices.
The findings point to a gap between having reporting processes in place and using the data they generate to drive meaningful cultural change. Reports handled in isolation, case by case, mean that early warning signs – recurring behaviours, issues linked to specific teams or locations, lower-level concerns that could escalate – risk being missed entirely.
Gemma McCall, co-founder and CEO of Culture Shift, said: “It’s positive that organisations are investing in reporting processes, and many are making real progress, but collecting data is really only the starting point. The real value and change comes from what organisations do with it – looking at reports collectively, identifying trends, and using those insights to act before issues escalate. Handling cases that have already happened is not the same as preventing them. The move from one to the other requires something that most organisations haven ‘t yet built: the analytical discipline to treat every report as a data point, not just a problem to resolve.
“With the strengthened duties under the Employment Rights Act coming into force in October, organisations will need to demonstrate not just that they have reporting processes in place, but that they are actively using the information they receive to prevent misconduct. That shift from reactive to proactive is where prevention really begins.”
The full findings are published in the Culture Shifters Report 26/27, which maps a survey of 300 senior HR professionals against research with over 1,000 UK employees to explore the gaps between organisational perception and employee experience across reporting, prevention, compliance and leadership.
The Culture Shifters Report 26/27 is available to download here.