Nine in ten HR leaders confident on ‘all reasonable steps’ compliance but fewer can evidence it
New research highlights a gap between compliance confidence and audit-ready evidence as Employment Rights Act strengthens from October 2026, requiring organisations of all sizes to take “all reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment.
New research has found that while the vast majority of HR professionals are confident that their organisation could demonstrate compliance with tightening sexual harassment prevention regulations, many currently lack the practical foundations to evidence it.
A survey of 300 senior UK HR professionals by Culture Shift found that 91% are confident their organisation could evidence taking “all reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment if challenged today. However, when asked which specific measures they could demonstrate having in place, audit-ready evidence was lacking for many.
Only half (50%) can evidence offering employees clear reporting processes, with the same proportion able to evidence documentation of actions taken after reports are made. Fewer still (41%) can evidence monitoring of repeat issues or patterns, while only 39% regularly share reporting data with the board or senior leadership team.
When it comes to wider safeguarding, just 38% can evidence thorough risk assessments around sexual harassment and only a third have measures in place to prevent retaliation – a critical area given that fear of personal risk remains one of the most common reasons employees choose not to report.
87% of those surveyed believe they are exposed to risk arising from workplace misconduct to some extent, with 1 in 5 saying their organisation is highly exposed – suggesting the gap between confidence and evidence is widely recognised, even if not yet fully addressed.
The findings are particularly significant given that the Employment Rights Act will require employers of all sizes to take “all reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment from October 2026. New protections around third-party harassment will also come into force, making employers potentially liable where employees are harassed by non-employees such as suppliers, clients or contractors, unless they can demonstrate that all reasonable steps were taken to prevent it.
Gemma McCall, co-founder and CEO of Culture Shift, said: “While most HRs understand the importance of getting this right there’s currently a sizable gap between confidence and having audit-ready evidence. As regulatory expectations around harassment continue to evolve, organisations need to be able to not only talk about what they’re doing to prevent harassment, but also tangibly evidence it.
“The confidence employers express about their compliance readiness sits in contrast to what’s happening in the employment tribunal system. Latest Government data shows that single claim receipts rose 55% year-on-year in the first quarter of 2026, with more than half a million tribunal cases now open: the highest level ever recorded. The gap between employer confidence and capability is precisely where tribunal risk lives – and it’s often the run-up to tribunal, not the hearing itself, where employers really take the financial hit. With employment tribunals able to increase compensation awards by up to 25% where the preventative duty has not been met, it’s crucial that employers get this right.”
The research forms part of a wider report which also revealed a disconnect between how safe HR professionals believe employees feel to report misconduct and what employees actually experience.
While 9 in 10 HR professionals said they believe employees within their organisation feel safe to speak up, separate Culture Shift research with over 1,000 UK employees found that almost 60% of those who have experienced bullying or harassment chose not to report it. In total, over a quarter of UK employees have experienced sexual harassment in the workplace.