Understanding our personal cues to provide true temperance
By Katie Roland
It was one of the worst meetings of my life. I received feedback that was inaccurate from someone I respected. Fury rose inside me. My stomach started to clench. I felt a heat that started in my belly rise up to my chest, making it feel like someone was sitting on it, and as that heat reached my face, I began to speak. My voice was steady and remained so throughout the conversation, however my body betrayed me.
As I spoke, focusing my energy on being clear and non-emotional, I was horrified to realize that tears had begun to pop out of my eyes unbidden. One by one they fell, underscoring my otherwise calm rebuttal. I tried to ignore and focus on the merit of my words, but each tear that escaped provided the unwanted stereotype, that I was an overly emotional woman. I watched my boss’s face change from startled, to regretful (for bringing it up not for being wrong), to uncomfortable and he said, “Maybe you need to go collect yourself”. I found myself saying rather forcefully, “I’m going to need you to focus on my words not the tears. I can’t control those, but I am very clear on what I’m saying.” I got my point across, and the tears eventually stopped, but I walked out of that meeting humiliated. Not necessarily because I cried, but because I couldn’t control it. My emotions hijacked my body and hurt my credibility, even though in the end he agreed his information was faulty.
That wasn’t the first time my emotions took the driver’s seat in the office, but I made certain it was the last time. I talked to my therapist, read articles and talked with other trusted mentors. I quickly realized my emotions weren’t the problem. In fact, having emotions and being empathetic is a key part to being an effective leader. It’s how we act on those emotions that define us. Anger wasn’t what undermined me in that meeting. It was the tears. If I had started to yell, or shut down entirely and then left in a huff, I would have done the same damage and I knew it. That is why I worked so hard to keep my voice calm and steady…but those damn tears!
For me, tears happen during any heightened emotion. If I’m really excited, tears. Really confused? Tears. They are the release that happens for me when I am flooded with emotion. In some situations, this isn’t a bad thing. It shows I care, that I am human. I have certainly allowed myself to cry in meetings when someone shared really bad health news, or when a beloved co-worker passed away. The key word there is allowed. I allowed my emotions to flood because it felt safe or appropriate.
Tears are not the only reaction to an onslaught of emotion. For some, it might be yelling or throwing things…ever been on the golf course when someone shanks an easy shot and you suddenly see a 9 iron flying across the fairway? Others get over-excited by the “what if” of an idea and make promises or commit resources that later, when thinking clearly, they realize are not available. When the body is flooded with an emotion, that emotion needs to go somewhere, and sometimes that is very unproductive.
So, knowing that I wanted to be an empathetic but consistent leader/employee, the question for me wasn’t how do I stop feeling, but rather, how do I remain in control? Through my research and a bit of trial and error, I learned two important things that help me to remain in control.
First, know your triggers. Triggers are things that you know cause big emotions in you. For me truthfulness and accuracy are very important to me, and hearing something I knew to be factually untrue about me was a quick trigger. I began to identify others. I thought back on times in my life that I felt emotions were leading my actions and found patterns. By knowing what triggers me, I can be more aware and keep my personal armour up. Additionally, I began to identify assumptions I was making in these moments. For example, I assumed in the conversation above I wasn’t going to be heard or believed which was driving the emotion. In reality, I explained the confusion, provided the receipts and the issue was over – except for the new one I caused with my reaction.
Since we are not clairvoyant, we can’t always know when those things are going to show up and when they do, they can be sneaky and we may not know exactly what we are reacting to until later.
Luckily, our bodies are more in tune to our emotions than our brains. Like a tornado warning, our bodies give us clear indications something big is happening. For me the clenched stomach, heat rising through my body and the tightening of my chest were all my body saying, “Hey! Fury has come out to play and is about to take over – please send reinforcements!” and by learning my body’s cues, I could help myself.
There are so many ways of regulating emotions. Each person has to do the work to learn what works for them. Here are some that work for me:
If I can take my time responding, I do. I take a walk before responding to a snarky email, do box breathing, or talk it out with someone I trust. Most recently, I’ve used AI to help me interpret what I’m reading or to temper what I want to write. The trickier part is when I have to react in the moment.
Scenario: You’re leading a conversation. It gets heated or maybe everyone is riled up and excited.
- Interrupt the flooding. When angry, you may clench your jaw/stomach/ legs, cross your arms, or your shoulders come up around your ears. In the case of excitement, maybe you start to gesticulate a lot. You jump out of your seat, your heart races. In these moments I deliberately sit back, uncross my legs, consciously drop my shoulders, and take a deep slow breath before responding. This signals to the nervous system that maybe the response it’s having isn’t the right one.
- Find a way to step away. This is ideal, but not always possible.
- “ I am so excited about this idea. We have a lot to think about, and I want to make sure we approach this in the right way. Let’s pick this up tomorrow.”
- “You’ve given me a lot to think about. I’d like to take some time before responding. Can we regroup after lunch?”
- “This is really interesting and I want to give it my full attention. Can we pause for a moment though…I need to handle something so I can refocus here.”
- Take a pause in the room.
Scenario: Someone has just shared they have made a mistake with your client.
Silence speaks volumes. While you get the moment or two you need, the person waiting for your response may fill the uncomfortable silence, giving you additional information you may not have gotten, including a possible solution.
- Ask for the pause you need. Thinking is not a weakness – neither is needing a moment to handle an intense reaction. “I need to think about this. Just give me a minute here to think.”
- Check for understanding. Repeat back what you heard. “Let me make sure I understand. You don’t think we should be moving forward with this project because you think X Is that accurate?” This may feel hokey at first, and you should adapt it to your own style, but it accomplishes two things. It lets the employee know how you heard the message they delivered. Sometimes, you make assumptions and this gives them an opportunity to clarify and you the moment you need to regulate.
- Be curious. Ask clarifying questions. This has helped me in a lot of tough moments. For me, the more I understand, the less emotional I become.
Scenario: Someone just made a complaint about your star employee. If you blow up and defend this person, you could have a disgruntled employee – which could lead to a lawsuit, justified or not.
- “I’m sorry this has been your experience, I’m surprised to hear it. I’d like to understand more, would you mind sharing additional details?” This buys you time and asks them to fill in some more blanks.
- “When you said she yelled at you. What did she say? Where were you?”
- “Can you give me examples of what you mean when you say she is treating you unfairly?”
- “I hear that she was upset with how you completed that task. What do you think she got wrong about that?”
These will give you more clarity on the situation. How serious is it? Is there a fix? Does this person just want to be heard? It also gives you a moment to think and focus.
Sometimes, depending on the situation, I’m 100% upfront about what is happening for me.
- “I’m going to be honest, I need a moment. I’m having a very strong reaction to what you just told me and that is not going to be productive to the conversation. Can we regroup in 5 minutes…after lunch…later today?”
This last one can be powerful but you I must advise caution. There are people that will not be receptive to this, or who will think it’s a weakness. However, I have had more than one employee thank me because they too needed a moment. In fact, I was the person thanking someone for showing me this tool. He was a peer and we were in a group conversation about an employee issue that was being led by our boss. Someone made a very offensive comment and my co-worker interjected a few moments later and said he was having a reaction to something that was said and needed a moment. He stepped away, came back and was able to have a really productive conversation that included discussing the offensive comment. To me, that not only showed maturity, but it was also a huge flex. I remember thinking, wow, he must be so confident! The reality was he needed to get his emotions in check, so he asked for what he needed.
None of this regulation happened overnight, it involved research, trial and error, and my own self reflection. To be honest, I’m still not perfect. While tears have not shown up unbidden in awhile, I still respond harsher than I meant to, or get defensive, but it happens rarely, and honestly, I’m ok with that, because it means I’m human. I apologize and repair when I should and strive to do better. Learning to identify my warnings and how to respond to them has made all the difference.
About a year after the tears, I found myself having to deliver difficult feedback to a senior employee. He didn’t like HR and he didn’t like me. He had a reputation of yelling and screaming and being bitingly sarcastic. The CEO didn’t want to deal with it, so I was nominated. I knew I was walking into my own personal trigger minefield, so I put on my armour. I walked into his office and sat down across from him. After a few pleasantries I kindly but firmly delivered the message. He lost it. He ranted, he yelled, he said people were liars. My stomach clenched. I felt the heat begin to rise, I had some particular choice words I wanted to throw back at him. Instead, I sat back in my chair slowly and opened my shoulders wide, laying both my arms gently on the arm rest next to me. I uncrossed and recrossed my legs. I consciously relaxed my face to look impassive and remained silent, looking at him. I breathed. To him, I was projecting a wry patience, the kind a mom has for a child that is throwing a temper tantrum. To me, I was taking the time I needed to gain control. I slowed my breath. While he ranted, I regulated. Eventually, he huffed back in his seat. Since I wasn’t fighting back, he ran out of steam. I remained silent another moment. When I spoke, it was in a conversational tone. I said ,“If that is how you speak to HR, I can only imagine how you speak to your employees.” He backpedalled. I wasn’t just projecting calm, I felt calm. The rest of the conversation was civil. He gave me an almost-apology, I finished addressing the issue, and we discussed next steps. Because I realized what was happening early, I was not only able to remain in control of my emotions, I remained in control of the meeting.
When I got home and gave my then boyfriend (now husband) the play by play, fury broke free for a bit, but it was because I let her, not because she hijacked my body.
Katie Roland is the Chief Human Resources Officer at KCSA Strategic Communications, a mid-sized agency delivering a unique brand of integrated communications that combines passionate, persuasive storytelling with pioneering strategies.