Why the Hire vs Reskill Maths Has Changed

Woman in suit shows document to man
by Oli Huggins.
Every HR leader I speak to is running the maths in their heads. There is a gap on the team, and the question is whether to hire someone new who claims they have the skill or upskill someone you already have. For most of the last decade the honest answer was to hire, because building capability in-house was slow, expensive, and hard to prove. That answer is now wrong, and the reason tells you something uncomfortable about how we have all been measuring skill.

AI has commoditised content. The tutorial, the course, the worked example, all of it is now generated on demand and close to free. Knowing a thing, in the sense of having seen the material, is no longer scarce and no longer worth much. What remains scarce is proof that a person can do the thing under real conditions, against a known standard, when it matters. That is the only part of the skills economy AI has made more valuable rather than less, and it is the part most HR functions are still not measuring.

Look at how the two options compare once you accept this. A new hire arrives with a CV, which is a set of claims, and an interview, which is a performance. You are buying a promise and finding out months later whether it held. An existing employee put through a verified reskilling programme arrives with evidence, because you watched them clear the bar. Reskilling does not win because it is cheaper to run (often it is not). It wins because you have removed the guesswork, and that is worth more than a few thousand pounds off a salary. This reframes what L&D is for. Its job is no longer to deliver courses, because the content underneath them is now a commodity anyone can summon. Its job is to certify capability, to issue proof a hiring manager or a customer can trust.

The practical move for 2026 is small. Pick one role you keep hiring for, define what good actually looks like as a test rather than a description, and find out whether someone you already employ can pass it. You will usually be surprised.

Oli Huggins is CEO of ExpertEdge (expertedge.org), which turns books from expert publishers including MIT Press, Wiley and Sage into verified courses.