Gender Pay Gap: Why the Real Problem Starts Long Before the Payslip
By Kim Croasdale
The UK’s gender pay gap is still widely discussed as a pay issue. But for women in the workplace, the gap is not the cause. It’s the consequence of navigating career and care.
New analysis from the TUC in 2026 showed that women effectively work 47 days a year unpaid compared with men. It is a stark figure, and it has prompted a legal requirement for large organisations to report their Gender Pay Gap annually.
But focusing on pay alone risks treating the symptom, without touching the system. The roots of inequality lie in how work is designed, how care is valued, and how flexibility is understood.
Care is still treated as a private problem…and women absorb the cost.
Care is not just the emotional labour of caring for children or elders. It’s the domestic admin of the weekly shop, changing the sheets, taking the bins out. It’s organising birthday parties and supporting those in need. None of this pauses because someone is employed. It must be done by someone, and in most UK households that “someone” is still a woman.
This unequal distribution shapes careers. The visibility of this is in who can attend early meetings, who can stay late, who can travel, who is visibly available, who is considered “reliable” and who might have to take a phone call from nursery during a board meeting.
These are not dramatic moments. These are hundreds of small decisions that are not necessarily down to choice. The consequence of that is structural disadvantage. According to ONS data, five years after their first child is born, mothers face an average monthly earnings reduction of £1,051.
For employers and policymakers, the question is no longer whether parents are supported. It’s whether workplace policies support parents to be equal partners at home, allowing them to equally participate in work.
The working week still assumes someone else is at home.
The 100-year-old full-time model was built for a world where one person earned and another person handled everything else. That world no longer exists, yet the structure remains.
It rewards constant availability and penalises anyone with caring responsibilities. Women pay the highest price. The consequence for their professional ambition is clear. More than a quarter of women don’t return to work after maternity leave, or resign within a year.
Flexible working is often framed as a wellbeing perk. In reality, it is a workforce design tool. When used well, it supports retention, productivity and long-term career sustainability.
The question for employers is shifting: are roles designed around outdated assumptions about availability, or are they designed around genuine outcomes?
Vague commitments to being “open to flexible working” are not effective.
Flexibility that relies on confidence to ask, negotiation skills to coordinate or a sympathetic manager to say yes is not a system. It is luck.
When only women or carers request flexibility, it becomes gendered. And when flexibility becomes gendered, it quietly harms the progression of that gender. The characterisation of women being less available becomes a stereotype of being less ambitious.
There are clear, visible options, such as compressed or annualised hours, staggered start times, job-sharing, term-time working and phased returns. These make flexibility normal rather than exceptional. Crucially, when senior men use these models, flexibility stops being coded as a women’s issue and becomes part of modern talent strategy.
Action plans must address the roots, not just the reporting.
Gender Equality Action Plans offer a major opportunity, but only if they move beyond compliance. It is too easy for tick-box plans to sit alongside Gender Pay Gap reports with great ideas and great intentions, but poor implementation means they won’t change the lived experience of work.
The real test is cultural, not administrative. Does the culture of the organisation allow fathers and partners to take the leave available to them? Are flexible working requests handled consistently? Are part-time staff considered equally for promotion? Are meetings and expectations designed around real lives, not idealised workers?
Policy becomes meaningful only when people trust it, use it and see leaders modelling it.
Reporting the gender pay gap measures the symptom. Updating policies addresses the surface. The deeper work lies in redesigning the conditions that create inequality.
Equalising care.
Normalising flexibility.
Designing work around outcomes.
Real, robust, practical support through life transitions.
These are the things that will ensure policies are lived, not just written.
A policy that employees fear using is not achieving its aims. A policy applied inconsistently is not supporting wellbeing. A policy that only benefits the most confident is not a positive contribution to culture.
For organisations preparing Gender Equality Action Plans, the opportunity is clear: move beyond compliance and build workplaces where women can stay, progress and lead.
Entela works with organisations to close that gap: going beyond the data to the design of work itself.
About the Author
Kim spent 15 years working in climate and sustainability, and almost a decade in NHS leadership, including contributing to the world’s first net zero healthcare strategy. Her work has always been about looking past symptoms to find the structural causes underneath, and solving those. After having 2 children and returning to demanding work, she saw how much of the pressure women carry is structural, not personal; a mismatch between what work expects and what the system actually supports. She founded Entela to help organisations build the conditions that let women stay and lead through the transitions that matter most. Find out more at www.entela.co.uk.”