Sickness Absence Calls Should Support Employees, Not Interrogate Them, Says BrightHR
Requiring employees to speak directly with their manager when reporting sickness can help organisations manage absence effectively, but HR teams should ensure policies remain flexible enough to accommodate workers who genuinely struggle to make a telephone call.
HR software provider BrightHR has highlighted the importance of striking that balance following comments from Sir Charlie Mayfield, the former chairman of John Lewis.
Sir Charlie was reported in The Times as calling for employees to contact their managers directly when they are unable to work because of illness.
BrightHR agrees there can be considerable value in manager-to-employee contact at the beginning of a sickness absence. A conversation can help establish immediate welfare needs, allow work and cover to be organised and give managers an indication of possible return-to-work timescales.
But the company says HR policies and management training should make clear that the purpose of such contact is not to challenge or interrogate an employee.
Alan Price, CEO at BrightHR, said: “I agree with Sir Charlie about the value of a direct conversation when an employee is sick. A phone call is often the quickest and best way to understand what support an employee needs. It’s also an opportunity to talk about work that may need to be covered while they are off and likely timescales on return to work.
“But a sickness call should never feel like an interrogation. Managers should focus on welfare and practical arrangements. They should never imply that an employee is letting the team down or treat an absence as suspicious. The purpose of the call should be to listen, respect confidentiality and focus on what the employee needs.
“Employers should set clear and consistent absence-reporting rules, but they also need to use judgment. If an employee’s health condition makes a call difficult, or there is another good reason why they cannot call, then they should make alternative arrangements such as sending a text or email, or having a relative call in.”
Consistency Should Not Come At The Expense Of Flexibility
For HR teams, having a clearly communicated sickness absence procedure can help ensure employees and line managers understand what is expected when somebody cannot attend work.
However, BrightHR says organisations should avoid applying those rules so rigidly that they create unnecessary barriers.
There may be circumstances in which an employee cannot reasonably make a telephone call. Allowing another method of notification, such as a text message, email or contact from a relative, can provide an appropriate alternative.
Manager training is another important consideration. Those receiving sickness notifications should understand what information is appropriate to discuss and how to approach potentially sensitive conversations without making an employee feel pressured or distrusted.
Employers should also consider what level of communication is appropriate throughout an absence, particularly when an employee is away from work for a prolonged period.
Occupational health advice and reasonable adjustments may be appropriate in some cases, while return-to-work discussions can help identify practical measures that could support an employee.
These could include a phased return to work, amended hours, lighter duties or more frequent check-ins while the employee readjusts to the workplace.
Price said: “If an employer stops all contact when an employee is off sick then they may feel abandoned. And the company loses the opportunity to put proper plans in place or discuss adjustments to help support them back to work. A conversation helps everyone, provided it is handled fairly and with respect.”
For HR professionals, the debate highlights the importance of balancing consistency with individual circumstances. A direct conversation can be useful, but the quality and purpose of that conversation — and an employer’s willingness to make appropriate adjustments — may be just as important as the method employees use to report their absence.