4,678 job adverts tracked from the hour they went live
The most contested job we tracked was not software. It was administrator.
Post a job advert and watch it for a day, and almost nothing happens.
We tracked 4,678 UK job adverts from the hour each one appeared. In thirteen of the seventeen occupations we can report on, the typical advert had received one application or none at all after 24 hours. Not the quiet corners of the labour market. Thirteen of seventeen.
Most hiring teams have never seen this, because most vacancy reports show days open rather than applications by advert age. So the first review happens on day one, the advert looks dead, and somebody starts rewriting it.
Wait three more days and the picture separates completely. That is where it gets interesting, because it does not separate the way the org chart would predict.
Applications after four days, median
Administrator: 11
Warehouse operative: 9.5
Payroll administrator: 8
Customer service advisor: 7.5
Receptionist: 7
Project manager: 4
Software developer: 1
Staff nurse: 0
Administrator, the role that gets a template advert and no board attention, is the busiest thing on our list. Software developer, which carries the shortage language and the retained search budget, sits on one.
At the busy end the gap widens further. The busiest tenth of receptionist adverts carry 81 applications by day four. For software developer the same figure is 19.
Staff nurse sits at zero, and three quarters of the nursing adverts we tracked had not received a single application after four days. One caveat belongs with that number rather than under it: these are Reed application counts, and NHS nursing recruits largely through NHS Jobs and TRAC, so a nurse may well see the advert and apply somewhere else. Occupational therapy does not route the same way and sits at zero too, which is why we lean towards the gap being mostly real. One job board cannot settle it, and we said the same when we published the nursing comparison at https://sausagedog.io/blog/receptionist-vs-nurse-applications
What this should change
Start with day one, because that is when most vacancy reviews happen. A dashboard read at 24 hours is reading noise. The advert that will end up with fifty applications and the advert that will end up with none look identical, because at that point they are identical.
That has a cost. Teams rewrite adverts on day two, escalate to agency support on day three, and open a salary conversation in week one, all on a signal carrying no information yet. Some of those vacancies were always going to fill. Some never were, and the rewrite was never the lever.
The more expensive mistake is the single service level agreement. Most organisations run one escalation rule across every vacancy: open this long, do this. One rule cannot serve both ends of that table. An administrator vacancy at zero applications on day four is genuinely unusual and worth a look. A staff nurse vacancy at zero on day four is the median outcome and means nothing has gone wrong yet. Fire the same trigger on both and you spend attention on the vacancy that did not need it while the one that did looks fine.
Then there is where the effort goes, which is the part worth taking to a leadership conversation. Advertising is a lever for roles where a queue exists and the problem is sorting it. For roles sitting at a median of zero, no wording change produces applicants who were never going to apply. That is a sourcing problem, a pay problem or a pipeline problem, and calling it an advertising problem for another six weeks is how a vacancy reaches month four.
The reverse holds too, and it gets less attention. If administrator adverts draw eleven applications in four days, the constraint on that hire is not attraction. It is your capacity to read applications properly. Eleven is enough to make a good hire and easily enough to make a bad one when the sift is rushed between other work. Very few teams resource the sift in proportion to the queue, because the queue never appears in the plan.
One number I would hold loosely. Software developer is the odd entry here, sitting at one application with a third of its adverts still at zero on day four, and its September intake behaved differently from its August one. The direction matches everything else we see in technical roles. The precise figure is the one I would want another month on.
Three things worth changing
Move the first vacancy review to day four. Nothing before that separates a healthy advert from a dead one, and a review that produces action on no information is worse than no review at all.
Set escalation triggers per role family, not per organisation. The threshold that flags a real problem in office support is a normal Tuesday in clinical recruitment. The single number you have now is almost certainly calibrated on whichever roles your team discusses most.
Split vacancies by whether a queue exists. Where it does, invest in sift quality and speed of reply. Where it does not, stop editing the advert and change something upstream. Those are different problems currently sharing one process.
None of this needs new software. It needs the vacancy report to show applications by advert age rather than days open, which most applicant tracking systems already hold and very few put on the screen.
Anthony Clasper is the founder of Sausage Dog, which tracks UK job adverts and tailors CVs against them.
Method: 4,678 UK adverts across 18 occupations, each recorded from the hour it appeared and observed 40 times between 1 August and 9 September 2026. We followed the same 2,336 adverts from day one to day four rather than comparing different vacancies. Application counts are Reed application counts as displayed on the advert. Four days is the common horizon because eight of the eighteen occupations are read for 96 hours and no longer, so no seven-day figure is quoted for them.
Anyone can check a live advert against the same reference at https://sausagedog.io/job-competition which is rebuilt daily. Figures in this article are the reading on 10 September 2026.