Not Everyone Is Meant to Be a Leader
Written By Laurie Maddalena, CEO & Chief Leadership Consultant at Envision Excellence
One of the best employees I ever worked with turned down a promotion.
As the vice president of human resources at a credit union, I supervised an exceptional HR
generalist named Eve. She was intelligent, dependable, and one of the strongest performers on
the team. She consistently delivered exceptional work, and everyone respected her. On paper,
she looked like the perfect candidate for leadership.
One day my manager, the CEO, suggested that I promote Eve into a management role. It
seemed like the natural next step, so I met with her to talk about the opportunity. Her response
surprised me. She told me she had no interest in becoming a leader. She realized that having
difficult conversations, managing personalities, coaching employees, and giving feedback were
not responsibilities she would enjoy or excel at. She loved the work she was doing and wanted
to continue to grow and develop in that position, but she didn’t want to manage people.
I admired Eve for her self-awareness. She understood her strengths, knew what she wanted in
her career, and wasn’t afraid to say no to a promotion that didn’t align with her interests, skills,
and talents. Most employees aspire to leadership without fully understanding what it truly
entails. Eve did, and she made the decision that was right for her.
Eve understood something that many organizations still struggle to recognize.
Not everyone is meant to be a leader.
That statement may sound controversial, especially in a culture that encourages us to believe
we can be anything we want to be. I certainly believe people have the capacity to learn, grow,
and pursue many different career paths. I also don’t believe anyone steps into a leadership role
with all the skills needed to be successful. Leadership can absolutely be learned and developed.
The problem isn’t that leadership can’t be learned. It’s that organizations rarely treat leadership
the way they treat other professions. We recognize that becoming a pilot, physician, teacher, or
accountant requires education, preparation, and demonstrated competence before someone is
entrusted with the responsibility of the role. Yet when it comes to leadership, we frequently
assume that because someone excels at their job, they’re ready to lead people.
Leadership deserves the same intentional preparation, professional standards, and ongoing
development we expect in every other profession.
That conversation with Eve taught me two important lessons that have stayed with me
throughout my career in leadership development.
The first is that we need to stop treating leadership as the automatic next step for every high
performer. Somewhere along the way, organizations created the expectation that if you’re
exceptional at your job, work hard, and consistently deliver results, the reward is a promotion
into management. Leadership became the default career path instead of one of several
meaningful career paths. Organizations need exceptional technical experts just as much as they
need exceptional leaders. Employees should be able to grow, increase their impact, earn more,
and continue developing in their careers without feeling pressured to manage people.
Leadership should be a career choice, not a reward for hard work or the only way someone can
advance professionally.
The second lesson is equally important. When employees do aspire to leadership and
demonstrate the potential to succeed, organizations have a responsibility to prepare them
before they move into a management role.
In nearly every industry I’ve consulted in, individuals are promoted into management and
executive roles without the preparation, training, or essential leadership skills needed to be
successful. Organizations often fail to identify the qualities, competencies, and behaviors
required for leadership before making promotion decisions. We continue to assume that
because someone is great at doing the work, they will naturally be great at leading the people
doing the work.
The reality is that technical expertise and leadership require very different competencies.
Leadership today is also more challenging than ever before. Effective leaders must provide
clarity for their teams, prioritize key results, nurture organizational culture, facilitate difficult
conversations, coach and develop employees, manage in hybrid and virtual settings, and
navigate a rapidly changing world where change is constant.
While managers could once succeed with a transactional, results-oriented approach, today’s
leaders must focus on positive influence while emphasizing trust, well-being, meaningful
relationships, and employee development—all while achieving results. This requires empathy,
flexibility, emotional intelligence, and the ability to adapt their leadership style to people with
different personalities, backgrounds, generations, and ways of thinking.
Unfortunately, many managers and executives are still relying on outdated leadership practices
because they were promoted without ever learning a different way to lead. Like many new
leaders, they simply manage the way they were managed.
One of the biggest shifts in leadership over the past several decades is the transition from being
a fixer to becoming a facilitator. In more traditional, transactional workplaces, managers were
often expected to direct the work, solve problems, and have all the answers. Today’s leaders are
expected to create the conditions where others can succeed by coaching, developing, and
empowering their employees. Exceptional leaders facilitate performance by instilling ownership
and accountability through coaching, supporting, and developing others. They spend less time
solving problems for employees and more time helping employees solve problems themselves.
Their greatest contribution is no longer their technical expertise. It’s their ability to develop the
people around them.
If organizations want healthier cultures and stronger leaders, we must rethink how we
approach leadership development. That begins by recognizing that leadership is not the right
career path for every high performer. It also means intentionally identifying and preparing
employees who have both the desire and the potential to lead before placing them in positions
of responsibility.
For HR professionals, this represents one of the greatest opportunities we have to influence
organizational culture. While we don’t make every promotion decision, we can help our
organizations redefine what leadership looks like, identify leadership potential before
promotions occur, and create development experiences that prepare people for the realities of
leading others. We can also advocate for meaningful career paths that allow employees to
continue growing and contributing without feeling that management is the only measure of
success.
When we stop treating leadership as the default destination for every high performer and start
treating it as a profession that deserves intentional preparation, everyone benefits. Employees
are free to pursue careers that align with their strengths, leaders are better equipped to
succeed, and organizations are better positioned to build strong cultures and achieve results.
When organizations create meaningful career paths for both technical experts and future
leaders, employees are empowered to pursue the path where they can make their greatest
contribution. And when we help our organizations identify the right leaders, intentionally
develop them before they’re promoted, and equip them with the skills to succeed, we don’t
just build better leaders—we build stronger organizations.
About Laurie Maddalena
Laurie Maddalena is a leadership provocateur and author of The Elevated Leader, confronting outdated leadership models that reward exhaustion over effectiveness. As the founder of Envision Excellence, she helps managers go from “The Fixer” to “The Facilitator,” enabling high-achieving leaders to deliver elite results without burnout.
A former VP of HR by age 30, Laurie is a Certified Speaking Professional and has worked directly with influencers like Brené Brown and Jack Canfield. Laurie intentionally caps her workweek at 40 hours—demonstrating that sustainable success and elite results are not mutually exclusive, but essential to modern leadership.
Featured Photo Copyright: https://doc.clickup.com/10593922/d/h/a39m2-50771/8ccf19868b1af51