The UK’s toughest jobs to get are often the easiest jobs to do
Anthony Clasper, Founder of sausagedog.io. Anthony has analysed thousands of UK job adverts to identify hiring patterns and recruitment trends.
If you advertise a receptionist role, the market will send you around 45 applications.
Advertise a nursing post and you’ll receive 2. Those are the median application counts across 1,657 live UK job adverts. Most discussion about the labour market revolves around vacancies and salaries. Vacancy figures tell us what employers want. Salary surveys tell us what they’re willing to pay.
Application numbers tell us something different.
They reveal how much competition actually exists.
Despite being one of the most useful indicators of recruitment difficulty, they are rarely analysed.
We examined application counts across 12 occupations and found something striking.
The UK’s labour market isn’t one market at all.
It’s several very different ones.
A twenty-fold gap
At one end of the scale, the median warehouse operative advert had 46 applications.
Receptionist roles followed closely with 45.
Administrator jobs attracted 25.
At the other end sat occupations employers have struggled to recruit into for years.
Nursing received 2 applications.
Teaching also received 2.
Healthcare assistants attracted 3.
Care workers received 4.
That represents around a 20-fold difference in competition.
Importantly, the pattern wasn’t explained by advert age.
Most adverts in every occupation had been live between one and six weeks. When applications were adjusted for the number of days each advert had been online, the gap barely changed.
Receptionist adverts attracted just over three applications every day.
Nursing and teaching adverts received roughly one application every ten days.
The imbalance remained.
The easiest jobs to apply for are often the hardest to get
What makes the findings interesting is what they don’t correlate with.
Not salary.
Not responsibility.
Not difficulty.
Nursing is degree-entry, professionally regulated and safety-critical.
Receptionist roles are commonly recommended to career changers because they appear accessible.
Yet one attracts two applicants.
The other attracts forty-five.
The explanation is relatively simple.
Roles without formal entry requirements are open to almost everyone, so almost everyone applies.
Jobs requiring professional registration, qualifications or unsocial hours naturally reduce the pool of eligible applicants before recruitment even begins.
The result is that the occupations many candidates view as their “safe” options often become the most competitive.
Our wider research illustrates this clearly.
In separate analysis of UK care adverts, 16% explicitly stated that no previous experience was required, the highest proportion of any occupation we measured, while around one in ten also advertised funded training opportunities.
The sector most frequently described as suffering recruitment shortages is, from an applicant’s perspective, one of the easiest doors into employment.
Why this matters for HR
For employers recruiting into crowded occupations, attracting applicants usually isn’t the problem.
Managing volume is.
Forty-five applications per vacancy means shortlisting quietly becomes the recruitment process.
Requirements expand.
Screening becomes inconsistent.
Time-to-review increases.
The strongest applicant is sometimes missed simply because they arrived in the middle of a very large pile.
Volume without structure often damages hiring quality more than applicant shortages ever do.
The opposite is true in shortage occupations.
When the median vacancy receives just two applicants, traditional recruitment processes become liabilities.
Lengthy closing dates.
Multiple interview stages.
Panel interviews scheduled weeks apart.
These processes assume choice.
In reality, the strongest applicant has often accepted another offer long before the second interview takes place.
For these employers, recruitment becomes a race rather than a selection exercise.
The same application data therefore points towards two completely different recruitment strategies.
One requires better filtering.
The other requires faster conversion.
Three things HR teams can do
Measure applications by role family, not organisation-wide.
Most applicant tracking systems already record applications per vacancy. Looking at the median by occupation quickly identifies which roles operate in completely different labour markets.
Redesign crowded recruitment around better screening.
Where vacancies routinely attract dozens of applicants, focus on objective shortlisting criteria, shorter review times and realistic essential requirements. Better filtering produces better hiring.
Redesign shortage recruitment around speed.
When vacancies receive only two or three applicants, every delay reduces the chance of making a hire. Shorter recruitment processes, rapid acknowledgements and faster offers often matter more than additional advertising.
One labour market doesn’t exist
We often talk about the UK labour market as though every employer is competing under the same conditions.
The data suggests otherwise.
Some employers are overwhelmed with applications.
Others wait days for the next one to arrive.
Until we recognise those are fundamentally different hiring markets, we will continue giving the same advice to organisations facing completely opposite problems.