Résumés Are Garbage: Why the Hiring Tool You Trust Most Is the One You Should Trust Least
By Jason P. Carroll
When I was scaling my last company from $20 million to $80 million before we sold, I kept having the same realization. Every single business problem was a people problem. Wrong people in wrong seats, leaders I didn’t know how to motivate because I didn’t understand what drove them, and my own shortcomings that I couldn’t see because nobody had ever shown me the data.
Somewhere in that stretch I discovered psychometrics, the idea that you could objectively measure the innate drives, needs, and motivators that predict how somebody is going to show up at work. Light bulbs went off everywhere. It changed how I led, how I hired, and eventually it became the reason I built Aptive Index after I exited. But the thing that struck me hardest was how little the tool we’d been relying on for decades, the résumé, had ever told us about any of it.
A Broken System, Made Worse
We’ve known résumés were flawed for a long time. That’s the whole reason applicant tracking systems exist, to try to filter through the noise and surface something useful. But the underlying document was always a weak proxy for whether somebody could do the job.
Now it’s worse. Studies from Harvard Business Review and Gallup have shown that roughly 74 percent of people admit to lying on their résumés. And that was before AI entered the picture. Today, ChatGPT writes just about every résumé that lands in our inbox. Candidates are using AI to polish, fabricate, and optimize their way past every filter we’ve built, which means we’re making decisions based on a document that was already unreliable and is now almost entirely manufactured. Most of us know that, even if we haven’t changed the process yet.
What Predicts Performance
Every operating system, EOS, Pinnacle, whatever else, talks about right people, right seats. We all know how important that is, but we keep trying to solve it with the wrong inputs. A résumé tells you what someone has done. It doesn’t tell you how they think, how they respond under pressure, what drives them, or where they’ll burn out.
When you measure for behavioral alignment and put the right person in the right role, they just don’t turn over. At that point, all you have to do is stick to your values and pay them well. But when it’s the wrong person in the wrong seat, no amount of experience on paper prevents what comes next: people butting heads, stretching into work that drains them, and eventually walking out the door. Harvard Business Review found that 80 percent of employee turnover traces back to bad hiring decisions, and most of those hires looked great on paper.
Who We’re Missing
Here’s what concerns me even more than the hires that don’t work out. It’s the people we never even consider because their résumé didn’t check the right boxes.
When I look at behavioral data, the profile doesn’t care about someone’s pedigree, their socioeconomic background, or whether they’re neurotypical. My own son is on the spectrum. I’ve got ADHD to the max. There’s no way you could tell any of that looking at our results, and if you could, that would be a legal liability. The chart is the chart.
What that means is behavioral data can surface hidden talent that résumé-first hiring systematically misses. Someone without traditional credentials might be a near-perfect behavioral match for a role, and we’d never know because their résumé got filtered out by an ATS before a human ever saw it.
I’m not talking about brain surgeons here. A brain surgeon better have the skill. But for most roles, people can learn the technical requirements in a reasonable amount of time if they’re wired for the work. Skills are trainable. Wiring is not.
One Leg of the Stool
I’m not saying burn every résumé. Skills and experience still matter, and they should be one leg of the stool. But that’s all they should be, one leg, and too many companies treat the résumé as the load-bearing wall of their entire hiring process and then wonder why the structure keeps cracking.
Behavioral assessment data is another leg. Cultural alignment, values, integrity, those are another. When I built Aptive Index, I built it as a hiring tool, and it surprised me more than anybody to see that hiring now accounts for about 30 percent of how our clients use it. They’ve expanded into conflict resolution, team building, leadership coaching, even pairing the right employees with the right clients. One couple told me our AI, ARIA, saved their marriage. I definitely didn’t build it for that, but I’ll take it.
The point is that once you have real behavioral data on your people, the applications go far beyond hiring, into how to lead, how to coach, how to get two people who are butting heads to hear each other.
Staying Curious
The mindset leaders need right now, more than any single tool or platform, is curiosity about people. The more we lean on AI for writing emails, coaching conversations, and strategy sessions, the more we risk disconnecting from the human element. These tools can pull us into our own little bubbles if we let them.
Remaining curious about how other people think, what motivates them, what their experience looks like from their seat, that’s what keeps leaders effective as the technology around us accelerates. The résumé was never going to tell you any of that. That gap is a big part of why we built Aptive Index, and why the companies using it keep finding new ways to apply it. The question is whether we’re willing to look deeper than the document we’ve all become so used to.
_____________________________________________
Jason P. Carroll is the founder of Aptive Index, an AI-powered behavioral assessment platform that helps companies hire, build teams, and develop self-aware leaders. He is a serial entrepreneur who has built, scaled, and successfully exited multiple companies.