Your workforce isn’t leaving – but is it still engaged?
By Sasha Watson, Chief People Officer at Zellis
Between March and May this year, UK vacancies fell by 31,000 compared with the same period in 2025. 2.5 unemployed people now compete for every vacancy – a ratio that has remained unchanged for months. This paints a picture of a labour market in a holding pattern. Employers are hiring cautiously in an uncertain economy, whilst employees are increasingly reluctant to move, favouring job security over new opportunities.
We’re nearly three years into what’s been called the Great Stay – the successor to the Great Resignation, when employees disillusioned with their jobs or careers just left. As the cost of living continues to rise, more and more people are staying put in their roles for financial security, and due to a lack of vacancies elsewhere, rather than because they’re fulfilled where they are.
Traditionally, high staff retention has been seen as a sign of positive workplace culture. That is, evidence that flexible working policies, DEI initiatives and skills development are landing effectively with employees. In the current UK context, however, low attrition can also mask a workforce that has mentally checked out whilst remaining physically present.
The hidden cost of employee apathy
Employee dissatisfaction has long been viewed as the warning sign leaders should pay closest attention to. As a result, the most vocal employees often receive the greatest focus. But the more significant threat is often far less visible. Employee apathy is quieter, easier to overlook and considerably more corrosive over time.
Businesses run on energy, initiative, and fresh ideas. An employee who complains still tends to drive all three of these things. They’re invested enough to want things to change and, more to the point, push for a better workplace. An employee experiencing apathy has lost this drive for progress, and that’s far more harmful to company culture and commercial outcomes alike.
The quiet red flags leaders are missing
Low attrition levels can disguise a workforce that is steadily becoming less engaged. With fewer employees leaving, organisations also lose one of their most valuable sources of insight: the exit interview. As a result, workplace tensions and the gap between expectation and reality can remain unrecognised for longer.
Early signs of apathy are subtle yet telling. A neutral survey response where there were once strong opinions suggests growing disengagement, as do declining participation in optional activities, reduced in-person attendance and a visible slowdown in cross-team collaboration.
When apathy affects performance
Employee apathy rarely stays contained. Left unchecked, it can spread through teams, weakening collaboration, slowing knowledge sharing and reducing discretionary effort. Over time, those subtle shifts begin to show up in lower productivity, weaker customer experiences and poorer commercial performance.
Organisations need to identify disengagement early and rebuild the connections between people and purpose, through meaningful career development and workplace experiences that keep employees invested.
Intervention is fundamental, and it comes down to four areas where organisations can act:
- Create opportunities for people to grow
Why fully engage when you can no longer see a future for yourself within an organisation? Employees are more likely to disengage when the role they hold starts looking like a dead-end.
Leadership should focus on providing genuine internal mobility, clear progression pathways and development opportunities that match the expectations set during onboarding.
Career growth should not be limited to promotions. Lateral moves, stretch assignments and skills-based development schemes can all help employees feel that they are moving forward, rather than standing still.
- Help people thrive and build confidence with AI
As AI reshapes the way we work, organisations must help employees develop the skills and confidence to adapt to its impact. Demand is growing for practical AI skills, such as prompt engineering and workflow innovation, alongside roles that embed AI across day-to-day operations. Adaptability is becoming as important as traditional role definitions, creating an opportunity to redesign how early careers develop.
AI adoption should be thoughtful: clear leadership and communication so AI is seen as supporting, not threatening, employees. The best outcomes come where AI is positioned as an enabler, not something imposed. Even small steps, like humanising AI tools through naming, can ease fear and build engagement.
- Make flexibility fair for everyone
Increasingly, employees are expecting greater autonomy over when, where and how they work.
However, organisations also need to recognise that frontline and office-based employees often have access to very different levels of flexibility. The most effective employers focus on equitable principles rather than umbrella policies, providing teams with the flexibility needed to work in ways that support both productivity and their wellbeing.
Even small adjustments can make a meaningful difference. Flexible schedules, autonomy over working patterns and practical support for working parents can help employees feel valued and, therefore, motivated to contribute.
- Put employees at the heart of inclusion
The most effective DEI initiatives are those that employees help shape and own. Many organisations are now broadening their focus to include topics such as menopause, neurodiversity and bereavement.
Employee resource groups (ERGs) can play a particularly important role here. Conversations driven by employees tend to land more authentically than campaigns dictated by the senior levels. Leadership should provide support, visibility and resources when needed, whilst giving employees the space to set the agenda and shape the conversation.