IR35 Off-Payroll: The Five Contract Clauses UK Businesses Get Wrong
By Irfan Dadabhai, founder of LexPact
In April 2021, the IR35 off-payroll rules shifted responsibility for contractor tax status onto the engager. Before that, a contractor working through a Personal Service Company (PSC) assessed their own IR35 status. Now, if you get it wrong, your business pays the unpaid PAYE and National Insurance — not them.
The stakes are real. HMRC’s IR35 compliance activity has increased significantly since the reform, and the investigations aren’t limited to large household-name employers. Medium-sized businesses with a handful of contractors are in scope. And what HMRC reads to decide if you’ve got it wrong is the contract.
Most HR teams are still using contractor agreement templates written years before this change. The commercial terms are fine. The IR35 language is often full of problems that nobody flagged because, until 2021, it wasn’t your problem to fix. Here are the five clauses where businesses consistently get this wrong.
1. Substitution rights
HMRC’s CEST (Check Employment Status for Tax) tool treats a genuine right of substitution as the single strongest indicator that a contractor sits outside IR35. The logic is straightforward: if someone else can do the work, there’s no personal service — and personal service is what defines employment.
The problem is in the drafting. “The contractor may provide a substitute, subject to prior client approval” sounds reasonable commercially. HMRC treats it as meaningless. If you can say no for any reason, the right doesn’t really exist. Substitution clauses need to be unconditional, or limited only by verifiable criteria — specific skills, qualifications, or security clearance requirements — not open-ended client discretion.
2. Mutuality of Obligation
Mutuality of Obligation (MoO) is one of the oldest tests in employment status case law, established as far back as Carmichael v National Power [1999]. It asks a simple question: is the engager obliged to offer work, and is the worker obliged to accept it? If yes to both, the relationship starts to look like employment.
Standard contract drafting almost always creates this dynamic without anyone realising it. The worker turns up, the client pays, and the arrangement rolls forward. Most templates don’t address MoO at all. The fix requires explicit language: each engagement confirmed separately in writing, no obligation on the engager to offer further work, no obligation on the contractor to accept it. One paragraph. Most contracts don’t have it.
3. Direction and control
There’s a clear line between telling someone what to deliver and telling them how to do their job. “Deliver X by [date]” is contracting language. “Work Monday to Friday, 9 to 5, using our systems and following our internal procedures” is employment language — and no preamble or recital in the contract undoes it.
Most contractor agreements blur this badly, often because they were adapted from employment contracts or service agreements written for a different purpose. HR teams should go through their standard template and flag any clause that specifies how work is to be done rather than what is to be delivered. That language is the problem.
4. Financial risk
A genuine business can lose money on a job. If your contractor gets paid regardless of the outcome — no exposure on a fixed fee, no liability if the work needs redoing — HMRC doesn’t see a business relationship. They see an employee with extra administrative steps around it.
Better contracts build real financial exposure in from the start: fixed-fee pricing rather than open-ended day rates where the project scope allows, explicit contractor liability for rework at their own cost, and no entitlement to payment for deliverables that don’t meet the agreed standard. These protections aren’t just good for IR35 — they’re better commercial contracts in their own right.
5. Integration
This one sits outside the contract itself, but it’s increasingly where HMRC focuses once the paperwork looks clean. A contractor who appears on your org chart, uses a company email address, attends staff all-hands meetings, and is introduced internally as “our new [role]” is integrated into your workforce in a way that no substitution clause can paper over.
HR teams should review contractor onboarding checklists with this in mind. The IR35 risk doesn’t stop at the contract. It runs through every system access request, every internal Slack channel invite, and every announcement that treats an external contractor the same way you’d welcome a new employee.
The bottom line
The 2021 reform made IR35 an HR problem, not just a legal or finance one. If your organisation engages contractors through PSCs, the agreements HR signs or inherits are now front-line tax documents. The good news is that most of these issues are fixable with targeted redrafting — you don’t need to start from scratch. A focused audit of your standard template against these five points is worth doing now, before HMRC flags it first.
Irfan Dadabhai is the founder of LexPact (lexpact.co.uk), a UK AI contract platform for businesses, recruitment agencies, and independent consultants.
Image – Unsplash