AI navigates, humans teach: why the industry is getting this the wrong way round
Businessman using smartphone with double exposure of creative blurry AI brain hologram. Concept of artificial intelligence. Toned image
By Brad Batesole, CEO and Founding Partner, Madecraft
HR leaders are under pressure to show they’re doing something about AI. The response, in a lot of organisations, has been to replace human instructors with AI-generated content. It’s faster to produce, cheaper to scale, and looks great in a presentation.
It’s also a mistake.
UK training investment is now at its lowest level on record. Budgets are tighter, expectations are higher and the temptation to reduce the human element and let AI fill the gap is understandable. But the organisations doing this are solving the wrong problem.
The issue with workplace learning has never been a shortage of content. It’s been a shortage of content people actually engage with and then apply.
Attention was never the problem. British adults now spend more time on their phones than watching television, an average of 3 hours 21 minutes a day. People are consuming content constantly. The question is whether workplace learning is worth their attention.
What AI is actually good at
AI has a genuine and valuable role in workplace learning. It’s just not the one most companies are giving it.
AI is exceptional at navigation and surfacing the right content for the right person at the right moment, like an algorithm that understands where someone is in their learning journey and what they need next. It removes decision fatigue. It makes personalisation possible at scale. It can turn a library of content into something that feels curated rather than overwhelming.
It can also do something L&D has struggled to do for years which is to connect learning activity to business outcomes. AI makes it possible to track not just who completed what, but which skills were applied and where performance changed. For HR leaders who spend budget review season justifying training spend, that’s not a small thing.
Used well, it’s the difference between a learning programme employees avoid, one they return to, and one that the business believes in.
But AI can’t replicate what makes human instruction work. People learn best from people. An expert who has actually done the thing, made the mistakes, and developed genuine insight brings something an artificial avatar can’t. Engagement, trust and the kind of nuanced judgement that comes from lived experience. None of it transfers through generated content however polished it looks.
The conversation HR needs to have
A lot of AI-generated content programmes exist because HR needed to show the business, they were taking AI seriously and not because there was a clear strategy. Vendor promises, board pressure and a genuine desire to modernise have pushed HR teams into decisions that were never fully thought through. That’s understandable. It’s also worth being honest about.
The same conversation needs to extend to business leadership. If the case for a learning programme is based on completion rates rather than capability built and performance improved, it won’t survive scrutiny for much longer. AI makes better measurement possible but only if HR is willing to be held accountable.
And with employees themselves. People know when learning is designed for the organisation’s convenience rather than their development. The organisations that are straight with their people about what they’re trying to achieve and build programmes that genuinely serve both, are the ones that see engagement that doesn’t need to be directed.
Getting the division right
The organisations that will get this right are the ones that assign AI and humans to what each does best.
AI navigates. It personalises discovery, surfaces relevant content, removes friction, and makes it possible for learning to happen in the moments already available in someone’s day rather than in a training session carved out of a diary.
Humans teach. They deliver the content, share the experience, and create the connection that makes learning stick. That’s not a romantic idea of human superiority, it’s what the engagement data consistently shows.
HR leaders who understand this distinction are in a strong position. Those who conflate AI’s role with instruction risk investing in a learning programme that scales efficiently and works poorly. Getting it wrong is what turns a learning investment into a box-ticking exercise that employees resent, doesn’t help the business succeed and HR has to defend at budget time.
The question isn’t whether AI belongs in workplace learning. It does. Just not at the front of the classroom.
Brad Batesole, CEO and Founding Partner at Madecraft
Brad Batesole co-founded Madecraft in 2018 after two decades at the forefront of online learning. At Lynda.com and LinkedIn Learning, he created top-performing marketing courses that amassed over 20 million views and built a LinkedIn following of 96,000 professionals. An internationally recognised speaker and storyteller, Brad advocates for learning strategies that match how people consume content today.